meganbmoore: (Default)
meganbmoore ([personal profile] meganbmoore) wrote2008-07-29 10:23 am

Twelve Reasons You Should Be Reading Claymore

*I posted this last night before bed, then realized most of you wouldn't see it because I forgot to backdate a private entry.*

I rarely do posts purely to say "Look!  New icon!" but this is a special icon.  And so:

Twelve Reasons You Should Be Reading Claymore:

1.  A large cast of female characters who are made badass for the reasons shounen manga usually uses to say "she can fight...but not as well."  Reflexes, an analytical mind, speed, a specialization in a certain field, etc. etc.  Instead of being excuses for not being "as good," these things are used to their maximum potential.  And if they have a shortcoming, they overcome it.

2.  A variety of strong and important female friendships(and other relationships.)  That pass the Bechdel Test in every way.

3.  Female characters who take on stereotypically male roles (badass loner with wee cute thing, analytical mastermind, noble warrior, one-eyed warrior with a mysterious past, vengeance driven youth, etc.) without coding as male or giving up any of their femininity.

4.  The most amazingly angsty and awesome shounen origin known to man.

5.  Female characters with fully developed back stories and motivations who are not remotely defined or identified by their relationships with male characters.  Any of them.  In fact, the opposite is true.

6.  Did I mention all the stoic warrior women with swords?

7.  A mangaka who is not afraid to kill off characters in situations where characters should die, and who does not play favorites.  A character who has been fully developed and fleshed out is just as likely to die as a Red Shirt, and a seeming Red Shirt is just as likely to live as an established character.  In addition, the deaths, even the minor ones, mean something.

8.  A complex (if initially slow to develop) plot where you think you know what the Big Reveal is and you're just waiting for one of them to come out and state it, but when they do, they reveal that what you think is the big secret is really just a minor thing in it.

9.  A manga kid in a primarily adult cast who isn't sickeningly sweet, abrasive, hyper-active, or any of the things most 10-12 year old boys in most shounen action are.

10.  One of the most impressive cases of  arm loss (and aftermath) I've ever seen.

11.  Breast feeding as a legitimate plot point.

12.  At one point, you will see a blind nun rip her habit to the waist and go off to rescue the Big Strong Guardsmen from the huge, rampaging monster.

ETA: [profile] magicnoirepointed out a grave error on my part.  I forgot to mention that, in an amazing case of gender reversal, the huge, rampaging monster is a huge, rampaging tentacle monster.  A huge, rampaging female tentacle monster.

Why 12 reasons?  Because that's how many licensed volumes have been released.  And yes, I did make this post just to mention the blind warrior nun.  

[identity profile] bellzooks.livejournal.com 2008-07-29 04:04 pm (UTC)(link)
12 has me thinking I have to seriously consider buying the anime, as well as the manga. Nuns who rip their habits to charge into battle are so worth the money.
Who needs food anyway? ^_^

[identity profile] meganbmoore.livejournal.com 2008-07-29 04:17 pm (UTC)(link)
Hmm. The anime is excellent for the most part, but it changes the ending of Pieta in a way that (1) keeps The Era of Awesometastic Badass Awesomeness from ever happening, (2) kinda falls apart and doesn't resolve anything. Which is annoying, and the end and immediate aftermath(just the first 2 chapters with Clarice) provide a good stopping point.

[identity profile] bellzooks.livejournal.com 2008-07-29 04:26 pm (UTC)(link)
Hmmm, thats a shame D: Does it change it in such a way to make you go "wtf, how on earth is the anime going to follow the manga now?" or is it tolerable? Perhaps I will download more of it (I have have only seen the first couple of episodes) to see how I feel about it before I set myself upon it.

[identity profile] meganbmoore.livejournal.com 2008-07-29 04:35 pm (UTC)(link)
Uhm...the anime's ending makes the manga after that impossible.

IMO, it's definitely worth watching, just get ready to be frustrated by the last couple of episodes.

One thing I will say in favor of the ending, though, is we do see Raki's reaction to realizing what Clare will eventually become, which I doubt we'll ever see in the manga.

[identity profile] bellzooks.livejournal.com 2008-07-29 04:49 pm (UTC)(link)
Oh no! That kind of sucks. I'll check it out anyway, if it is worth watching despite that then it sounds like it must be pretty cool.

Awesome! I do like Raki a lot, and the recent developments with him seemed really promising.