meganbmoore: (yuna got badass)
meganbmoore ([personal profile] meganbmoore) wrote2008-09-25 11:02 pm

manga: The Young Magician Vol 1

This is one of those books that plops you down in the middle of the action without explaining anything, then drops bits and pieces to help you catch up. Except, by the end of the first volume, there haven’t been enough details dropped to really be able to piece the whole thing together.

The plot, as near as I can tell, this that there’s a magician serial killer loose in Hong Kong. The style of his murders has resulted in his being labeled “Jack the Ripper.” The killer, it seems, is a renegade of the Guino Clan, and is murdering women in a form of magic that lets him use their blood and entrails to see the future. The Guino Clan, in response, sends Carno, a young magician who is more than a little wild, and doesn’t have good control over his powers or strength. Accompanying him is his “sister,” Roselite, who raised him and has looked 10 years old since Carno was five. Or seven. I think the translation actually says both. Jack’s current target is a young woman named Monica, who he and his underling have been purifying, but she’s rescued by Carno and Roselite. For now. We’ll see how that goes.

There are also modern Knights Templar, which is a secret weakness of mine. They find Carno after the As Yet Unexplained loss of his biological family. The Guino Clan is apparently not a clan in the biological sense, but more a collection of magic users. According to the cover blurb, they also live in another dimension. That isn’t explained in the book itself, but it helps explain a few things. Several times, I thought the book was actually saying Roselite is actually dead, but I’m not sure. The volume ends with the storyarc still underway, so I assume I’ll know one way or the other by the end.

Oh, and “Jack” gives his underling his eye. By somehow turning it into goo that comes out of his mouth and enters his underlings eyesocket. Except it may not have originally been a real eye.

Carno is also apparently only one of two main protagonists, with the other one not showing up this volume.

Is this a confusing manga? Yeah, pretty much. Things are clearer by the end than they are in the beginning, but still not cleared up enough to completely say what’s going on. Apparently, CMX realizes this, and pretty much details out what we can expect to be explained in the next volume. It’s also pretty interesting, with an apparently complex mythology, plot, and system behind it, and has interesting characters. And Carno’s Super Power (and what’s been revealed of his nature and origin) alone is enough to warrant reading at least a little more. One thing I did find extremely offputting, though, is that the volume starts off with a woman being murdered, and the displaying her body in a somewhat sexualized pose with her chest spread open, and her insides pulled out.

And this, I think, ends the adventures in new CMX shoujo. (I actually would have thought this one was shounen, just reading it, but I’ve checked several places, and they say shoujo.)
ext_12512: Hinoe from Natsume Yuujinchou, elegant and smirky (Default)

[identity profile] smillaraaq.livejournal.com 2008-09-26 08:28 am (UTC)(link)
Is that really a new trend, though? -- going by the women-in-refrigerators list of examples, there's been a tendency in Western comics for quite a while of sexualized posing when female characters have been assaulted or killed that you don't see nearly as often when male characters are the victims of violence; and while I don't have any hard cites on hand, I'd be very, very surprised if you couldn't find examples of that going back to even the days of the EC horror comics, or pulp paperback covers. And in manga, well, even leaving aside the weirdness of all-eroticized-violence-and-gore-all-the-time guro, I've certainly seen plenty of examples of sexualized positioning/depiction of female corpses in violent chanbara (manga and film alike) going at least as far back as the 1970s...

[identity profile] aphelion-orion.livejournal.com 2008-09-26 10:49 am (UTC)(link)
It's certainly not new, but judging by how widespread it's become, it's a bit worrisome to me. And by widespread, I mean that shows like those America's Next Topmodel thing have young girls posing as rape and abuse victims, or even outright corpses, and voting their performances as "beautiful" or "sexy", or that you get a ton of extremely detailed shots at corpses in films and series. I'm not saying there weren't shows like that earlier on, because that's a lie, but I remember times when most crime and detective shows would barely even film the victim, if at all. It's just a question of whether we need to look a corpse in every orifice, especially if it's a pretty young girl.

It's a wider trend that has been on the increase lately, and that's what's bugging me.

[identity profile] meganbmoore.livejournal.com 2008-09-26 03:06 pm (UTC)(link)
Yeah, nowhere near new, but it does seem to be more and more the trend. I wouldn't have watched more than the first few episodes of S1 of The Cloaser if I hadn't seen S2-S3 eps where, yes, there were actually episodes that did not involve women being killed for reasons directly relating to sex and sexuality.