The Uncrowned King by Michelle West
Jul. 25th, 2008 02:46 amUnlike The Broken Crown, The Uncrowned King is set almost entirely in Essalieyan, with barely any of the action in the Dominion. This, of course, means that Diora, marginally the main character of the first book, wasn’t in the second book of the series, aside from one passing mention. No, that was not a happy realization for me.
Replacing Diora is Valedan, a prince who has to prove himself worthy of being king in the middle of a House War. Actually, it’s probably more accurate to say that Jewel replaced Diora as the main character, and Valedan took Jewel’s place as secondary lead. I’m assuming (hoping) Diora is back in the next book. I admit, I’m not quite sure what I think of Valedan, at least partly because I spent a lot of his sections going “but where’s Diora?” I suspect he’s being set up to be someone’s love interest, though I don’t know who.
I have to say, without the contrast of the oppressive (and almost depressing) Dominion, Essalieyan isn’t quite as fascinating a place, as it stands out a little more that it’s a fairly normal medieval fantasy kingdom. So far, this sounds fairly critical of the book, but really, I don’t feel critical about it, it’s just that the way it dropped the main plotline of the first book to focus exclusively on the secondary plotline was something of a shock.
I did, of course, love Jewel’s storyline, dealing with herminions Den (and Avandar, of course) and her role in the house war. I can’t quite decide if Avandar is her pet bull dog or her self-appointed babysitter. Maybe both. Kiriel’s story, with her learning more about what it is to be human, is very interesting, but I’m not quite sure what I think of her. I like her, but in many ways, she’s a typical fantasy heroine, while Diora and Jewel aren’t. Diora is an extremely traditionally female character, with all the traits usually used to make female characters in fantasy weak and disposable trophies instead used to make her a strong survivor. Jewel is a former street rat and thief turned noble, with an excellent, functional, and practical take on both the den mother and seer tropes. Kiriel...is a spirited young warrior girl with a destiny.
And now I realize that I’m not sure if the next book I have is book 3 or book 4.
Replacing Diora is Valedan, a prince who has to prove himself worthy of being king in the middle of a House War. Actually, it’s probably more accurate to say that Jewel replaced Diora as the main character, and Valedan took Jewel’s place as secondary lead. I’m assuming (hoping) Diora is back in the next book. I admit, I’m not quite sure what I think of Valedan, at least partly because I spent a lot of his sections going “but where’s Diora?” I suspect he’s being set up to be someone’s love interest, though I don’t know who.
I have to say, without the contrast of the oppressive (and almost depressing) Dominion, Essalieyan isn’t quite as fascinating a place, as it stands out a little more that it’s a fairly normal medieval fantasy kingdom. So far, this sounds fairly critical of the book, but really, I don’t feel critical about it, it’s just that the way it dropped the main plotline of the first book to focus exclusively on the secondary plotline was something of a shock.
I did, of course, love Jewel’s storyline, dealing with her
And now I realize that I’m not sure if the next book I have is book 3 or book 4.