In Ashes Lie by Marie Brennan
Aug. 2nd, 2009 02:12 amSet several decades after Midnight Never Come, In Ashes Lie covers the Onyx court, the fae sister city to London, from the years of 1639 to the great fire of London in 1666. While Midnight Never Come focused on the story of Lune and Devon and the mystery of the link between London and the Onyx Court, In Ashes Lie focuses on the connection between Lune and the Onyx Court, and what that means for England.
The story is told nonlinearly, with the climax in 1666 spread throughout the book as framework, with the rest of the book covering the years leading up to it. These parts, too, are nonlinear, with each scene marked with a place and date. It should be confusing, or at least cluttered, but isn’t, and works surprisingly well. With Midnight Never Come I was somewhat put off in the first fourth of the book because it felt like the politics were getting in the way of the plot. If anything, In Ashes Lie has even more politics, but worked intrinsically into the plot so that they propel the book.
It’s a very different book from its predecessor, but in a way that is neither better nor worse, just independent. That said, I don’t think it can be read and properly understood without Midnight Never Come as both the plot and Lune’s motivations and reasoning rely on the events of Midnight Never Come. (I have deliberately avoided most plot details to try to avoid spoiling Midnight Never Come much, and because most things specific to In Ashes Lie are either specific to expectations from Midnight Never Come, or require spoiling more plot points to explain them.)
The story is told nonlinearly, with the climax in 1666 spread throughout the book as framework, with the rest of the book covering the years leading up to it. These parts, too, are nonlinear, with each scene marked with a place and date. It should be confusing, or at least cluttered, but isn’t, and works surprisingly well. With Midnight Never Come I was somewhat put off in the first fourth of the book because it felt like the politics were getting in the way of the plot. If anything, In Ashes Lie has even more politics, but worked intrinsically into the plot so that they propel the book.
It’s a very different book from its predecessor, but in a way that is neither better nor worse, just independent. That said, I don’t think it can be read and properly understood without Midnight Never Come as both the plot and Lune’s motivations and reasoning rely on the events of Midnight Never Come. (I have deliberately avoided most plot details to try to avoid spoiling Midnight Never Come much, and because most things specific to In Ashes Lie are either specific to expectations from Midnight Never Come, or require spoiling more plot points to explain them.)