Everyone has fictional tropes they hate, both big and small. Usually, we bring up major ones that are easily recognized or agreed on, or that there are strong opinions on for both sides. A strong woman has to be raped, falling in love with your kidnapper, all the “raising your wife” variations (mentor/ward, student/teacher, guardian/ward, etc.), angsty immortal finds love with pure mortal, destined hero with great powers/destined to wield magic weapon, etc. You know, the ones that get done to death. And, really, I like harping on them as much as anyone, but what about others? What are some tropes that bug you that don’t come up as much.
Here are a couple of mine:
1. Confession of Love as Your True Love is About to Marry Someone Else
Now, don’t get me wrong. If Baron Dastardly is holding Lady Virtue’s Angelic Younger Sister hostage or some such, and Knight Gallant shows up and announces that Angelic Younger Sister has been rescued and is safe with his Noble Underlings (insert alternate coercion of choice), then I’m all for Lady Virtue kicking Baron Dastardly in the shin and running off with Knight Gallant to make virtuous and gallant babies. But if Lady Virtue is marrying Baron Dastardly of her own free will, and the reason Baron Dastardly is there beside her instead of Knight Gallant is that Lady Virtue and Knight Gallant couldn’t work their problems out or one couldn’t get over their issues and/or get their act together, then I’m not going to be convinced that it’ll all work out due to a last second confession made under pressure. If things have proceeded to Lady Virtue being 5 minutes from marrying the wrong guy of her own free will, then there’s probably a lot more wrong with their relationship than can be fixed that easily. Ditto for Lady Virtue having a last second revelation and realizing that she’s making a mistake just as she’s about to say “I do.”
( more )
So, there are a couple of mine. What are yours? Here’s the TV Tropes page for inspiration if you want. (WARNING: can cause addiction!)
Please leave “TSTL heroines” and “supposedly strong female characters who are useless” and the like at the door. That path us so well trod that it has ruts.
Here are a couple of mine:
1. Confession of Love as Your True Love is About to Marry Someone Else
Now, don’t get me wrong. If Baron Dastardly is holding Lady Virtue’s Angelic Younger Sister hostage or some such, and Knight Gallant shows up and announces that Angelic Younger Sister has been rescued and is safe with his Noble Underlings (insert alternate coercion of choice), then I’m all for Lady Virtue kicking Baron Dastardly in the shin and running off with Knight Gallant to make virtuous and gallant babies. But if Lady Virtue is marrying Baron Dastardly of her own free will, and the reason Baron Dastardly is there beside her instead of Knight Gallant is that Lady Virtue and Knight Gallant couldn’t work their problems out or one couldn’t get over their issues and/or get their act together, then I’m not going to be convinced that it’ll all work out due to a last second confession made under pressure. If things have proceeded to Lady Virtue being 5 minutes from marrying the wrong guy of her own free will, then there’s probably a lot more wrong with their relationship than can be fixed that easily. Ditto for Lady Virtue having a last second revelation and realizing that she’s making a mistake just as she’s about to say “I do.”
( more )
So, there are a couple of mine. What are yours? Here’s the TV Tropes page for inspiration if you want. (WARNING: can cause addiction!)
Please leave “TSTL heroines” and “supposedly strong female characters who are useless” and the like at the door. That path us so well trod that it has ruts.