manga: Rasetsu Vol 2
Sep. 9th, 2009 10:02 pmReview at There It Is, Plain As Daylight.
This volume was mostly about the history between Mikage, the priestess who founded Aria's line, and Kagara, the demon who killed, and was killed by, Mikage 400 years ago. Now, here's the thing: I like the "enemies as lovers" bit, but very conditionally. As a general rule, you have to convince me that no, nothing about the plot could possibly work without it, such as in Basara, for it to work. That Romeo and Juliet "oh, woe, our families hate each other and instead of using our brains and dumping them, we will angst a lot and then kill each other" stuff isn't my thing. At all. (Side note: I don't really call the "oh, I've heard so much bad stuff about you that I'll reject you until you prove that you're not so bad, or at least willing to make really dramatic gestures for me that usually involve a trail of dead or unconscious bodies" bit "enemies as lovers" as it's more "bad boy/good girl" most of the time.)
There is, however, one time I'll almost always fall for it: when you bring in reincarnation and make the "enemies" part against the will of the principles. Siblings/friends/lovers/whatever forced into being enemies due to that pesky past lives things almost always works for me. And since Night of the Beasts is centered around that, Japanese mythology and a strong heroine, it's no wonder I love it so.
This volume was mostly about the history between Mikage, the priestess who founded Aria's line, and Kagara, the demon who killed, and was killed by, Mikage 400 years ago. Now, here's the thing: I like the "enemies as lovers" bit, but very conditionally. As a general rule, you have to convince me that no, nothing about the plot could possibly work without it, such as in Basara, for it to work. That Romeo and Juliet "oh, woe, our families hate each other and instead of using our brains and dumping them, we will angst a lot and then kill each other" stuff isn't my thing. At all. (Side note: I don't really call the "oh, I've heard so much bad stuff about you that I'll reject you until you prove that you're not so bad, or at least willing to make really dramatic gestures for me that usually involve a trail of dead or unconscious bodies" bit "enemies as lovers" as it's more "bad boy/good girl" most of the time.)
There is, however, one time I'll almost always fall for it: when you bring in reincarnation and make the "enemies" part against the will of the principles. Siblings/friends/lovers/whatever forced into being enemies due to that pesky past lives things almost always works for me. And since Night of the Beasts is centered around that, Japanese mythology and a strong heroine, it's no wonder I love it so.
Volume one of Canon set the series up to be a very good, if standard in concept, book about a girl who wanted revenge revenge on the vampire who killed her friends and was joined by a vampire who also wanted revenge against the same man. The main thing that made it stand out from the norm was that Sakaki, the hero to Canon's heroine, seemed to be just as bad and as ruthless as Rod(I shall never stop loving that he is "Rod, the Vampire Lord"...I feel confident it sounds MUCH better in Japanese...rather like Oh! Great! is probably a cool name for a mangaka...somewhere...) Volume 2, however, rather turns that idea on its head.
Volume one of Canon set the series up to be a very good, if standard in concept, book about a girl who wanted revenge revenge on the vampire who killed her friends and was joined by a vampire who also wanted revenge against the same man. The main thing that made it stand out from the norm was that Sakaki, the hero to Canon's heroine, seemed to be just as bad and as ruthless as Rod(I shall never stop loving that he is "Rod, the Vampire Lord"...I feel confident it sounds MUCH better in Japanese...rather like Oh! Great! is probably a cool name for a mangaka...somewhere...) Volume 2, however, rather turns that idea on its head.
When I read vol 1 of Yurara, I liked it, but was a bit disconcerted by how shojo-like it was. That may sound odd as, like Chika Shiomi's other books, it is shojo, her books tend to be shojo more because they're about girls who kick butt than for the usual shojo hearts and flowers and romance. Canon destroys the idea of the romantic vampire, portraying even the "heroic" and apparently eventual love interest as a near monster, and Night of the Beasts is like a romantic fable gone horrible dark and wrong in the best way possible. Yurara, about a teeny, clumsy girl who sees ghosts who meets two boys-cold and slightly sadistic but secretly nice Yato, and open goofbal with a darkside Mei- who are exorcists, respectively using water and fireas mediums, was just so tame and mainstream in comparison.
But I'm over that now, and while I don't love it quite as much as Night of the Beasts, I do love it. It's more of the normal shojo high school adventures and romantic triangle than the other two, but not so much so that it annoys me, and it works well. While either Aria or canon could squash Yurara(normal Yurara or Guardian Spirit Yurara) like a bug, I do like her, and I find Mei, with his outer goofball and inner dark angster very engaging. I'm still most interested, however, in the oh-so-serious and repressed Yato. Who, sadly, seems destined to be on the losing end ofthe romantic triangle, and hasn't got as much attention as Mei yet.
I admit, though, that I wish there wasn't so much emphasis on "spurred by love/desire ghosts." In this volume, there's the girl whose boyfriend dumped her while she was dying for another girl, the pervert ghost who hit on any female ghost he could find and tried to keep them, and, of course, the ghost of Mei's dead love, who was herself possessed by another ghost to try to kill him(yes it sounds a bit convoulted, but it makes perfect sense in the book.) Balancing it out, though, we have the ghost of Mei's mother, who won't move on because she knows her husband and three sons are the world's biggest skirtchasers, and is convinced that the moment she's gone, they'll be bringing girls home.
On an unrelated note, I'm a bit disgruntled with the new Novik book. In terms of quality, plot and execution, it's just as good as the first three books, but for some reason, it isn't grabbing me the way they did. I tore through each of the first three books in as close to one sitting as I possibly could, but with this book, I put it down after reading the first part to read Yurara. But I'm picking it back up now.
When I read vol 1 of Yurara, I liked it, but was a bit disconcerted by how shojo-like it was. That may sound odd as, like Chika Shiomi's other books, it is shojo, her books tend to be shojo more because they're about girls who kick butt than for the usual shojo hearts and flowers and romance. Canon destroys the idea of the romantic vampire, portraying even the "heroic" and apparently eventual love interest as a near monster, and Night of the Beasts is like a romantic fable gone horrible dark and wrong in the best way possible. Yurara, about a teeny, clumsy girl who sees ghosts who meets two boys-cold and slightly sadistic but secretly nice Yato, and open goofbal with a darkside Mei- who are exorcists, respectively using water and fireas mediums, was just so tame and mainstream in comparison.
But I'm over that now, and while I don't love it quite as much as Night of the Beasts, I do love it. It's more of the normal shojo high school adventures and romantic triangle than the other two, but not so much so that it annoys me, and it works well. While either Aria or canon could squash Yurara(normal Yurara or Guardian Spirit Yurara) like a bug, I do like her, and I find Mei, with his outer goofball and inner dark angster very engaging. I'm still most interested, however, in the oh-so-serious and repressed Yato. Who, sadly, seems destined to be on the losing end ofthe romantic triangle, and hasn't got as much attention as Mei yet.
I admit, though, that I wish there wasn't so much emphasis on "spurred by love/desire ghosts." In this volume, there's the girl whose boyfriend dumped her while she was dying for another girl, the pervert ghost who hit on any female ghost he could find and tried to keep them, and, of course, the ghost of Mei's dead love, who was herself possessed by another ghost to try to kill him(yes it sounds a bit convoulted, but it makes perfect sense in the book.) Balancing it out, though, we have the ghost of Mei's mother, who won't move on because she knows her husband and three sons are the world's biggest skirtchasers, and is convinced that the moment she's gone, they'll be bringing girls home.
On an unrelated note, I'm a bit disgruntled with the new Novik book. In terms of quality, plot and execution, it's just as good as the first three books, but for some reason, it isn't grabbing me the way they did. I tore through each of the first three books in as close to one sitting as I possibly could, but with this book, I put it down after reading the first part to read Yurara. But I'm picking it back up now.
For Him: How to carry on a courtship when you’re possessed by two demons who are ancient enemies:
Yes, still loving this one. I really do despise the relatives…really, the only flatout likable ones are Tohru, who’s really barely more than a kid and isn’t all “Kill Sakura! KILL KILL KILL!!” and Towako, who mostly wants all the idiots to shut up and start whining. Akiya and Takikaido are both interesting, but are both destined to end up either broken shells or with their entrails dangling from Kagara’s fingers.
Night of the Beasts remains my favorite of Chika Shiomi’s books. I loke both Canon and Yurara a lot, but compared to Aria, both their heroines are pushovers, and while Canon has promise in the “messed up psycho OTP area” Yurara doesn’t really show signs of it, and I like the history and mythology in Night of the Beasts.
For Him: How to carry on a courtship when you’re possessed by two demons who are ancient enemies:
Yes, still loving this one. I really do despise the relatives…really, the only flatout likable ones are Tohru, who’s really barely more than a kid and isn’t all “Kill Sakura! KILL KILL KILL!!” and Towako, who mostly wants all the idiots to shut up and start whining. Akiya and Takikaido are both interesting, but are both destined to end up either broken shells or with their entrails dangling from Kagara’s fingers.
Night of the Beasts remains my favorite of Chika Shiomi’s books. I loke both Canon and Yurara a lot, but compared to Aria, both their heroines are pushovers, and while Canon has promise in the “messed up psycho OTP area” Yurara doesn’t really show signs of it, and I like the history and mythology in Night of the Beasts.
Yurara is the third title by Chika Shiomi(Night of the Beasts, Canon) to be licensed in the US. It's about a girl named Yurara, a shy, meek girl who sees spirits and can feel their emotions, but can't interact with or do anything about them. At her new school, she gets placed between Mei, and overly affectionate goofball and Yako, and cold and serious student, in her new class. Almost immediately, she learns that both boys can also see spirits, and that Mei can use spiritual flames to fight them, and Yako can bind them and create barriers with water. Apparently, meeting them allows her guardian spirit, a more forceful version of herself, to awaken, allowing her to communicate with the ghosts and help them move on.
Of Shiomi's three books that have been licensed, Yurara is, in both art and story, the most conventional. On the one had, just based on this, I'll take it over most of the high school manga out there, fantasy/paranormal or otherwise. On the other, after the urban hunt of Canon and dark mythology of Night of the Beasts, something so close to "normal" shojo felt like a bit of a let down(yet is likely closer to what most on my flist would like, anyway, as I tend to sometimes have odd tastes, so I guess it's ok.) In comparison, it, and its characters, kinda of start to blend in with the rest(plus, as compared to Canon and Aria, Yurara is kind of a doormat, guardian spirit or not-not that I didn't like her, I did, just that those two are very strong and very kickbutt.)
If I hadn't read Shiomi's other books, I'd probably be praising this book left and right-as compared to other shojo, it is pretty unique and it has an interesting story, and it's not just "magical girl and cute protectors," it just didn't quite live up to the expectations Canon and Night of the Beasts set for me. (incidentally, at 6 volumes, Night of the Beasts is Shiomi's longest series of the three...nice to know some mangaka regularly keep it short and sweet instead of making their books last for all eternity.)