meganbmoore: (archer)
A sequel to Rite of Conquest, but operating largely independent of it, this is a historical fantasy about two sons of William and Mathilda, William Rufus and Henry, and Edith (later Mathilda), who became Henry’s wife when he became king. I found Rite of Conquest enjoyable if not stunning, and entertaining despite the revisionist history. This, though, I was rather “meh” about.

William and Henry are both pretty whitewashed, and the romance between Edith and Henry, which is delivered as Epic True Love, is literally based on “I fell in love with you when we had sex without knowing each other’s names.” There was also way too much “those nasty Saxons were killing England with their icky Christianity, but the Normans will save England by invading and reestablishing awesome pagan ways.” Though nowhere near to the degree of that one Marion Zimmer Bradley book I read, and without the severe “the only way to make a maligned mythic woman look good is to demonize the ‘good’ mythic woman” thing.

meganbmoore: (sibylla)
This historical fantasy focuses on William the Conquerer and his wife, Mathilda (Or Maud, or Matilda, whichever you prefer), from William’s youth through the battle of Hastings.

Tarr knows her history pretty well, but still plays fast and loose with it at times, and not just with the fantasy aspects. Here, a somewhat romanticized William is a reincarnation of King Arthur, and he and Mathilda are both descended from druids. The Saxons have all but driven magic from England, and Norman rule (specifically, William) is meant to fix that. The first half focuses on the early (and rather ahistorical) courtship of William and Mathilda, which is actually Mathilda (who seems to serve the role of Merlin, Morgan, and Guinevere, at different points) teaching him how to handle his magic and destiny, and ending with their marriage.

Unsurprisingly, Mathilda is largely on the sidelines in the second half (As we all know, women don’t do much once they’re wives and mothers, though being husbands and fathers doesn’t affect men.), which focuses more on the Norman and Saxon politics, and much of her page time is given to Harold.

A pretty good read, but not a very involving one, and some of the uses of both history and mythology made me go “Oh really?” in different ways.

As an aside, anyone have any good books about Guinevere to rec? The only one I’ve read is Kim Headee’s Dawnflight (which, IIRC, was supposed to be the start of a series, but I guess didn’t do well enough, unfortunately).

Profile

meganbmoore: (Default)
meganbmoore

July 2020

S M T W T F S
   1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26 2728293031 

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jun. 23rd, 2025 11:27 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios