![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
Random Claymore thought...
Aug. 8th, 2008 02:26 am ...that's somewhat of the depressing variety.
AKA: Megan shouldn't think in the shower.
AKA: Megan shouldn't think in the shower.
Aug. 8th, 2008
The Yuukos
Aug. 8th, 2008 01:55 pmLately there seem to be a lot of the "mysterious shop owner/deal maker with ties to the supernatural" manga coming out. Even though Pet Shop of Horrors predates it by quite a bit, I kind of think xxxHolic's popularity contributes a lot to how many are being licensed. It also tends to naturally cause people to gravitate towards thinking the other books are ripoffs. I think it's a natural assumption, btw, even if it's an incorrect one, not only because Petshop of Horrors was never-as far as I know-as big as xxxHolic, but also because the licensing filters awareness of other books in the genre(s), and can skew our perception of when things came out. For example, Yumekui Kenbun Nightmare Inspector is on (I think) vol 2 in the US, and has both visual and thematic elements in common with xxxHolic, which just had vol 12 come out in the US. In original publication, however, xxxHolic came out a year or two later. (I looked it up earlier this week, but am too lazy to go check the exact period of time between publication now.)
Anyway, I'm curious. What all books have come out in the genre in the US? (And i mean as the prominent theme. Urahara in Bleach and-I understand-Kou in Wild Adaptor are of the character and thematic type, though Urahara is eventually more of a cog in the megaplot, but they and their shops aren't the focus of their individual series.)
Off the top of my head, there's:
Antique Gift Shop
Fairy Cube*
Hell Girl**
Legal Drug***
Nightmares for Sale
Petshop of Horrors
Petshop of Horrors: Tokyo
Tarot Cafe
xxxHolic
Yumekui Kenbun Nightmare Inspector
*I'm on the fence regarding this one, actually. On the one hand, Kaito's shop and his plotty stuff is pretty central to the plot, but on the other, it isn't the focus. Hm...Probably shouldn't count it, but it could still end up revolving around that later on. Probationary status, maybe?
**I'm counting the website, as people specifically go there to acquire her services. Pretty much applying the idea as a whole to modern tech, instead of the "small shop" nostalgia.
***At least, as I understand it-this one I haven't read yet.
Anyone have any others? (I swear I'm forgetting at least one I read/have read.)
Or, for that matter, thoughts on the genre in general? I tend to automatically grab the books when I see them, but I can't quite pin down why I love the genre so much.
And if you know of others, can you mention licensed/unlicensed? Purely for purposes of acquisition.
Your Scandalous Ways by Loretta Chase
Aug. 8th, 2008 10:35 pmNote: Despite the length, all plot details are either on the back, or in the first few chapters, so I don't consider this spoilery beyond the one hidden bit. Which is also in the first few chapters.
James Cordier is a spy for England in 1820, using his looks to seduce women suspected of being enemies of the crown. He knows that he’s expendable and can be easily replaced by another good looking guy willing to do all for king and country, and so he does his best to both get the job done without annoying his superiors, and to not get killed by his enemies. His latest mission is to go to Italy and seduce Francesca Bonnard, a woman who supposedly has letters that could prove her ex-husband a traitor, and reveal his entire network. Francesca, of course, isn’t about to give up the leverage she has on him, and has proved to be more than a bit recalcitrant when asked for the letters in the past. So James is sent to seduce them out of her. Insert romance novel game of cat-and-mouse. And since it’s Loretta Chase, you know it’ll be pretty good.Ignore that book with the blond haired, blue eyed Arab spy masquerading as a Frenchman. Every author is allowed a dud. Possibly, it was the result of a Gundam Wing induced fever dream.
Except, did you catch that one word? The “ex-husband” one? In 1820? There weren’t exactly that many reasons to end up divorced then, and not that many options open for divorcees. You see, five years ago Francesca had an affair to get revenge on her husband for his own affairs. In response, he saw to it that her father was driven out of England as a con-artist, and dragged her through the courts as an adulteress, destroying her reputation, before throwing her penniless into the streets. Normally in a romance novel, some kind friend or relation will come and pack the heroine off to the country, or she will change her name and become a companion to some elderly lady in the country. She will live in guilt and shame, fearful of her secret being discovered, until the hero comes along and his healing love brings her out of her shell, and she timidly goes out into the world, fearful of rejection.
Francesca? Moves to the continent and becomes a courtesan. A high class courtesan sought after by princes and dignitaries. She never feels shame for what he did to her, and never apologizes for who and what she is.
Cue the romance novel community going insane. A promiscuous heroine? Who feels no shame? Who actually likes sex? Who doesn’t need the hero’s approval? The most awful thing they’d ever heard of! The wank was amazing. People swear to never read Loretta Chase again. They say this is the most revolting plot they’ve ever heard of. They are appalled that she actually likes sex before meeting James, and that she isn’t ashamed of it. My favorite but, I think, was when they talked about how no well bred woman would become a courtesan if she had a choice, that being a divorcee was a bad thing that cut off options, etc. Basically, they didn’t even bother to read the book. Otherwise, they would have noted that that was rather the whole point: that her life was destroyed, and that the only option she had was that or starving. I’m sure they especially went ballistic when she had sex with another man after meeting, and even making out with James. Even worse, the other guy wasn’t revealed to be OMG EVIL BECAUSE ANYONE SHE LIKES AFTER MEETING THE HERO HAS TO BE!!! And that Francesca and James even helped matchmake him and her friend.
But Chase doesn’t stop there. She goes even a step farther. You see, the whole “spy who sleeps around a lot as part of his duties” bit is pretty popular with romance novels. He’s always angsty. Oh so very angsty. And noble and heroic and ohnononono…he isn’t a prostitute with the government as his pimp! Really! James? Is pragmatic, angst-lite, and well aware that a prostitute is exactly what we is, and nothing else. He wants out because he’s tired of it. In fact, he wants to go to England and dance at Almacks with dim little virgins hunting for a husband. He wants the life most romance novel heroes avoid like the plague.
Loretta Chase, as a general rule, is quietly subversive. She twists and bends romance novel tropes all over the place while working squarely within them. Here, she kicks them in the face. The “virgin or shame” rule? Torn into shreds. The “noble manslut for king and country” trope? Exposed as the shallow excuse (and pretty much lie) that it is.
The result? A book worlds better than most of its target audience will ever appreciate, because it exposes the problems with so many of its comfort zones, while presenting a hero and heroine who would mop the floor with all their “acceptable” and “proper” heroes and heroines.
James Cordier is a spy for England in 1820, using his looks to seduce women suspected of being enemies of the crown. He knows that he’s expendable and can be easily replaced by another good looking guy willing to do all for king and country, and so he does his best to both get the job done without annoying his superiors, and to not get killed by his enemies. His latest mission is to go to Italy and seduce Francesca Bonnard, a woman who supposedly has letters that could prove her ex-husband a traitor, and reveal his entire network. Francesca, of course, isn’t about to give up the leverage she has on him, and has proved to be more than a bit recalcitrant when asked for the letters in the past. So James is sent to seduce them out of her. Insert romance novel game of cat-and-mouse. And since it’s Loretta Chase, you know it’ll be pretty good.
Except, did you catch that one word? The “ex-husband” one? In 1820? There weren’t exactly that many reasons to end up divorced then, and not that many options open for divorcees. You see, five years ago Francesca had an affair to get revenge on her husband for his own affairs. In response, he saw to it that her father was driven out of England as a con-artist, and dragged her through the courts as an adulteress, destroying her reputation, before throwing her penniless into the streets. Normally in a romance novel, some kind friend or relation will come and pack the heroine off to the country, or she will change her name and become a companion to some elderly lady in the country. She will live in guilt and shame, fearful of her secret being discovered, until the hero comes along and his healing love brings her out of her shell, and she timidly goes out into the world, fearful of rejection.
Francesca? Moves to the continent and becomes a courtesan. A high class courtesan sought after by princes and dignitaries. She never feels shame for what he did to her, and never apologizes for who and what she is.
Cue the romance novel community going insane. A promiscuous heroine? Who feels no shame? Who actually likes sex? Who doesn’t need the hero’s approval? The most awful thing they’d ever heard of! The wank was amazing. People swear to never read Loretta Chase again. They say this is the most revolting plot they’ve ever heard of. They are appalled that she actually likes sex before meeting James, and that she isn’t ashamed of it. My favorite but, I think, was when they talked about how no well bred woman would become a courtesan if she had a choice, that being a divorcee was a bad thing that cut off options, etc. Basically, they didn’t even bother to read the book. Otherwise, they would have noted that that was rather the whole point: that her life was destroyed, and that the only option she had was that or starving. I’m sure they especially went ballistic when she had sex with another man after meeting, and even making out with James. Even worse, the other guy wasn’t revealed to be OMG EVIL BECAUSE ANYONE SHE LIKES AFTER MEETING THE HERO HAS TO BE!!! And that Francesca and James even helped matchmake him and her friend.
But Chase doesn’t stop there. She goes even a step farther. You see, the whole “spy who sleeps around a lot as part of his duties” bit is pretty popular with romance novels. He’s always angsty. Oh so very angsty. And noble and heroic and ohnononono…he isn’t a prostitute with the government as his pimp! Really! James? Is pragmatic, angst-lite, and well aware that a prostitute is exactly what we is, and nothing else. He wants out because he’s tired of it. In fact, he wants to go to England and dance at Almacks with dim little virgins hunting for a husband. He wants the life most romance novel heroes avoid like the plague.
Loretta Chase, as a general rule, is quietly subversive. She twists and bends romance novel tropes all over the place while working squarely within them. Here, she kicks them in the face. The “virgin or shame” rule? Torn into shreds. The “noble manslut for king and country” trope? Exposed as the shallow excuse (and pretty much lie) that it is.
The result? A book worlds better than most of its target audience will ever appreciate, because it exposes the problems with so many of its comfort zones, while presenting a hero and heroine who would mop the floor with all their “acceptable” and “proper” heroes and heroines.